Florida Attorney Accused of Breaking Into Ex-Girlfriend’s Home After Breakup, Sending Her Messages From Inside

A Florida attorney is facing criminal charges after allegedly breaking into his ex-girlfriend’s home just one day after their relationship ended, then sending her a barrage of messages claiming he was waiting for her inside.

Andrew Inserra, 41, a personal injury lawyer from Fort Lauderdale, allegedly entered the woman’s residence in Boca Raton without permission on June 2, 2026. According to police, he sent her photographs taken inside the home and repeatedly contacted her, including messages saying he would see her when she returned.

The woman told investigators that she had not invited Inserra to the property and was alarmed when she received a photograph of her bathroom. The case led to charges involving burglary, aggravated stalking and allegedly impersonating a police dispatcher.

Allegedly Entered Home Through Unlocked Door

According to a probable cause affidavit cited by Law&Crime, the woman and Inserra had ended their relationship the previous day.

The woman said she was at home when she received a photograph of her bathroom from Inserra. Although the front door and living room sliding door were secured, the sliding door in her bedroom had been left unlocked.

Investigators allege that Inserra entered the residence through that door and took multiple photographs of the property’s interior.

Police later examined his phone and reportedly found images showing the exterior sliding doors, the front door, the kitchen island and the bathroom. One bathroom photograph was timestamped at 6:48 p.m. and matched the image he allegedly sent to the woman.

Location data associated with the photographs reportedly placed his phone at the woman’s residence.

According to the affidavit, investigators found no messages indicating that the woman had invited him to visit.

“I’m F—ing Waiting,” He Allegedly Texted

After allegedly entering the home, Inserra reportedly sent his ex-girlfriend a series of messages describing where he was sitting.

One message stated that he was sitting on her gray couch and waiting for her. He allegedly added that he would see her when she got home.

In another message, he reportedly challenged her about contacting police, writing: “Where the f— are the police honey, cause you’re not on your way here.”

The woman told investigators that Inserra repeatedly claimed to be waiting inside the residence.

According to police records, the volume of communication was substantial. One message thread allegedly contained 108 messages and 30 attempted phone calls. A separate thread reportedly showed another 65 messages and 77 calls, despite the woman not responding.

The woman eventually told Inserra to stop contacting her and said she intended to seek a restraining order, according to the affidavit.

Police Say Attorney Pretended to Be a Dispatcher

Investigators also accused Inserra of impersonating a Boca Raton police dispatcher in an attempt to communicate with his former girlfriend.

The alleged conduct added another dimension to the investigation, as authorities examined not only the reported unauthorized entry but also the repeated communications and the use of a false identity.

Police interviewed Inserra on June 3 while he was in custody on an unrelated traffic infraction.

According to the affidavit, Inserra initially claimed that the bathroom photograph was an old image and said he had been home all night. He later alleged that the woman had invited him to her residence.

He reportedly declined to provide investigators with the passcode to his phone but confirmed that the device belonged to him and was the only phone he used daily.

Investigators cited the photographs, timestamps, location data and messages as evidence in the case.

Attorney Faces Multiple Criminal Charges

Inserra was charged with burglary of an unoccupied structure, aggravated stalking and false personation after allegedly posing as a police officer or dispatcher.

Law&Crime reported that authorities arrested him in October 2026, several months after the alleged June incident. The reason for the delay between the reported incident and the arrest was not immediately clear.

The charges are allegations, and Inserra is presumed innocent unless proven guilty in court.

The case raises concerns about alleged stalking and unwanted contact following the end of a relationship. Investigators say the messages and photographs were central to establishing what allegedly happened inside the woman’s home.

Source: Law&Crime