SUSAN SMITH SEEKS PAROLE AGAIN 32 YEARS AFTER DROWNING HER TWO YOUNG SONS — THEIR FATHER DAVID SMITH VOWS TO KEEP HER BEHIND BARS FOR LIFE

More than three decades after one of South Carolina’s most notorious crimes shocked the United States, Susan Smith is preparing to make another attempt at freedom.
Smith, now 55, is scheduled to appear before the South Carolina Board of Paroles and Pardons on November 19, 2026, seeking release from the life sentence she received for the 1994 killings of her two young sons, Michael and Alexander.

Her former husband and the boys’ father, David Smith, has made clear that he will oppose her release once again. He says the passage of 32 years has not erased the pain of losing his children and believes Smith should remain incarcerated for the rest of her life.
In recent interviews, David has spoken about the lasting emotional consequences of the tragedy, his concerns about the possibility of parole and the difficulty of revisiting a case that continues to affect his family more than 30 years later.
The upcoming hearing will be Smith’s second opportunity to seek parole. Her first application was unanimously rejected in November 2024.
As the new hearing approaches, the case has once again brought attention to the two children whose lives were taken and the father who has spent decades living with their loss.

THE OCTOBER 1994 CRIME THAT SHOCKED THE NATION
The case began on October 25, 1994, in Union County, South Carolina.
At the time, Susan Smith was 22 years old and the mother of two young boys: Michael, who was 3, and Alexander, commonly known as Alex, who was just 14 months old.
That evening, Smith reported that a man had carjacked her vehicle while her children were inside. She claimed that the stranger had driven away with the boys, triggering an extensive search and an emotional public appeal for their safe return.
The story quickly attracted national attention.
Smith appeared before television cameras alongside David Smith, pleading for help and asking whoever had taken the children to bring them home. Their photographs circulated widely as investigators and members of the public searched for answers.
For nine days, the disappearance remained a major news story. Authorities investigated the alleged carjacking while the children’s parents made public appeals.
But the account Smith had given investigators eventually began to unravel.
On November 3, 1994, she confessed that there had been no carjacking. She had driven her vehicle to John D. Long Lake in Union County with Michael and Alex still strapped into their car seats.
She allowed the vehicle to roll into the water while the boys were inside.
The children’s bodies were recovered from the lake the following day, November 4.
The confession transformed what had initially been treated as a desperate search for two missing children into a criminal investigation involving their own mother.
The case devastated David Smith and shocked people across the country, particularly because Susan had spent days publicly asking for her sons to be returned while concealing what had actually happened.

THE TRIAL AND LIFE SENTENCE
Susan Smith was arrested and charged in connection with the deaths of Michael and Alex.
Her trial began in July 1995 and attracted extensive national media coverage.
Prosecutors argued that Smith had killed her children because she wanted to pursue a relationship with Tom Findlay, the son of a wealthy local businessman with whom she had been romantically involved.
According to the prosecution’s theory, Findlay did not want children, and Smith believed that her sons stood in the way of the relationship she hoped to maintain.
The defense presented a different explanation, focusing on her mental health and emotional difficulties. Her attorneys argued that she had been struggling psychologically and that her mental condition played a significant role in the events of that night.
The jury ultimately found Smith guilty of two counts of first-degree murder in July 1995.
Prosecutors had sought the death penalty, but jurors chose not to impose it. Instead, Smith received a life sentence with the possibility of parole after 30 years under the law applicable to her case.
She began serving her sentence on July 28, 1995.
That sentence meant she would eventually become eligible to ask for release, even though she had been convicted of taking the lives of her two young children.

HER FIRST PAROLE REQUEST WAS REJECTED IN 2024
Smith became eligible for parole after serving approximately 30 years of her life sentence.
Her first parole hearing took place on November 20, 2024, when she appeared before the South Carolina parole board through a video connection from prison.
During the hearing, she acknowledged the seriousness of what she had done and expressed regret.
Smith told the board that she was deeply sorry for her actions and said she would give anything to go back and change what happened.
She also spoke about her religious faith, explaining that she believed God had forgiven her and asking the board to show her mercy.
Her defense emphasized her mental health history, her behavior during incarceration and the argument that she could be released without posing a significant risk to the public.
However, the hearing also included powerful opposition from David Smith and other members of the family.
David spoke about the permanent loss of his children and the emotional consequences that continued to affect him decades later.
His wife, Tiffany Smith, and their daughter Savannah also opposed Susan’s release.
The board ultimately voted unanimously against parole.
The decision meant Susan would remain incarcerated and could apply again under the applicable parole schedule.
That second opportunity has now arrived.

DAVID SMITH SAYS 32 YEARS HAVE NOT EASED HIS PAIN
Ahead of the November 19 hearing, David Smith has again spoken publicly about his opposition to his former wife’s potential release.
In an interview with FOX 5 Atlanta, he expressed a clear preference that Susan remain in prison until the end of her life.
He explained that the loss of Michael and Alex is something he continues to carry every day, regardless of how many years have passed.
David also told PEOPLE that he has little interest in hearing another explanation from Susan.
He said he has already reached his own understanding of what happened and does not believe another statement from her would change anything.
His comments reflect a position he has maintained since the first parole hearing: he does not believe the time Susan has served is sufficient for the crime committed against their children.
David has also expressed concern that the board could reach a different decision in 2026.
Although he hopes the outcome will be another denial, he does not regard that result as guaranteed.
He wants the board members to understand that the passage of time has not removed the consequences of the crime from his life.
For him, 32 years is not simply a figure on a calendar. It represents decades without the two sons he expected to watch grow up.
A PAINFUL REMINDER OF THE CHILDREN HE LOST
In one of the most heartbreaking aspects of his recent interviews, David has spoken about how difficult it has become to remember certain details about his sons.
Michael and Alex were extremely young when they died. Michael was only 3, while Alex was 14 months old.
Because their lives ended so early, David has few memories of the experiences they might have shared as they grew older.
He told PEOPLE that he can remember a few things they used to say, but many of the everyday memories a parent normally builds over years are no longer available to him.
He also spoke about the emotional impact of knowing that strangers continue to visit the children’s graves.
Some visitors leave flowers, small gifts and other personal tributes in memory of Michael and Alex.
David said those gestures mean a great deal to him because they show that people who never knew the boys personally still remember them and care about their story.
The attention is a reminder that Michael and Alex have not been forgotten, even though more than three decades have passed.
For David, however, public remembrance cannot replace the opportunity to raise his sons, watch them grow and experience the ordinary moments of family life that were taken away.
TIFFANY SMITH ALSO OPPOSES HER RELEASE
David’s wife, Tiffany Smith, has also spoken out against the possibility of Susan receiving parole.
She supported David during the 2024 hearing and is expected to remain firmly opposed to release.
Tiffany has questioned whether Susan has demonstrated sufficient accountability for what happened to Michael and Alex during her years in prison.
She has also expressed frustration that a person serving a life sentence for taking the lives of two children can become eligible for release after three decades.
Her position is that the sentence should reflect the permanent consequences of the crime.
The family believes the parole board must consider not only Susan’s conduct while incarcerated but also the nature of the offenses and the impact on those who survived the tragedy.
Their opposition is not simply about David’s personal relationship with his former wife. They want the board to consider the two children who were unable to live beyond their earliest years.
QUESTIONS ABOUT SUSAN SMITH’S BEHAVIOR IN PRISON
Smith’s conduct during incarceration is also expected to remain part of the discussion surrounding her latest parole request.
Over the years, she has received several disciplinary infractions, including incidents involving contraband, cigarettes and violations of institutional rules.
Two particularly serious incidents involved sexual relationships with prison employees.
In 2000, correctional officer Houston Cagle was disciplined and later pleaded guilty in connection with having sex with Smith.
In 2001, prison captain Alfred Rowe was also involved in a case concerning a sexual relationship with her and received a criminal sentence of probation.
These incidents became part of the public record surrounding her time behind bars.
More recent reporting has also highlighted that Smith has not earned educational credits during her incarceration.
Her supporters and defense representatives may point to aspects of her behavior, personal development or mental health as reasons to consider release. Her critics, including David and Tiffany, argue that her disciplinary history and what they view as a lack of genuine accountability should weigh against her.
The parole board will have to consider the information presented during the hearing rather than relying solely on public opinion.
WHAT WILL HAPPEN AT THE NOVEMBER 19 HEARING?
Smith’s second parole hearing is scheduled for Thursday, November 19, 2026, before the South Carolina Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services.
She is expected to participate by video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood County, where she is currently incarcerated.
The board consists of seven members, and Smith needs support from at least two-thirds of them to receive parole.
That means a majority alone would not be enough.
David Smith and members of the family are preparing to oppose her release, continuing the position they presented during the 2024 hearing.
The original prosecutors involved in the case are also expected to oppose parole.
The decision will determine whether Susan remains incarcerated or is granted an opportunity to leave prison under parole supervision.
If her application is denied again, she would generally have to wait until the next eligible review period, expected in 2028, before making another request.
As of the time of this report, the November 19 hearing is scheduled, but a final decision has not yet been confirmed.
A CASE THAT CONTINUES TO HAUNT A FAMILY 32 YEARS LATER
More than 30 years have passed since Michael and Alex Smith were taken from their father.
Susan Smith has spent most of her adult life in prison, while David has had to rebuild his life after losing both children in circumstances that became known around the world.
The upcoming parole hearing brings the family back to a painful chapter that they have repeatedly had to revisit.
For David, the central issue remains the same: Michael and Alex never had the opportunity to grow up, and he believes their mother should not be allowed to return to society.
He has said that he intends to keep opposing her release for as long as necessary.
The board must now weigh the information presented by Smith, her representatives, the victims’ family and others involved in the case.
Whatever the outcome, the decision will not change the events of October 25, 1994, or the permanent loss experienced by those who loved the two boys.
Michael was only 3 years old. Alex was just 14 months old.
Their names remain at the center of a case that continues to draw public attention more than three decades later.
For their father, the years have passed, but the loss has never become something he can simply leave behind.